Serving Dinner Monday Thru saturday We start serving nightly at 5 p.m. *all food can be ordered to go but there will be a $1.00 charge per order
 
Appetizer Selections Wisconsin Cheese Curds: Large portion of yellow cheese curds fried till the cheese screams to escape. Served with your choice of dipping sauce....$8.95 Pickles Deep Fried: 5 pickle spears hand breaded in Toby’s special mixture, fried to perfection and served with homemade ranch dressing....$6.95 Onion Rings: Thick cut onion rings fried to golden brown and piled high. Served with your choice of dipping sauce....$7.95 Chicken Strips: Southwestern breaded tenders fried to perfection with your choice of dipping sauce....$8.95 Corn dogs: 12 mini corn dogs fried to golden brown and served with ketchup & mustard… the perfect dipping combo....$7.95 Mozzarella Sticks: Wisconsin mozzarella cheese sticks served with marinara sauce....$7.95 Breaded Mushrooms: Whole mushroom caps breaded with choice of dipping sauce....$8.95 Chicken Drummies: 7 Large crispy drummies served with choice of dipping sauce....$10.95 Pretzel Bites: 15 Warm soft and chewy bites with Wisconsin beer cheese for dipping....$7.95 Sides French Fries....$4.00 Baked Potato....$3.50 Loaded Potato....$5.00 (cheddar, bacon and green onions) Hash Browns....$4.00 add cheese....$0.50 Steamed Broccoli....$3.50 Steamed Asparagus....$4.00 Steamed Brussel Sprouts....$4.00 Green Beans....$3.00 Green Peas....$3.00 Cole Slaw....$3.00 Cottage Cheese....$3.00 Dinner Salad....$3.00 Apple Sauce....$2.50 Home Made Soup of the day Cup....$4.00 Bowl....$6.00 ALL DINNERS ARE SERVED WITH CHOICE OF SALAD OR SOUP, POTATO, RELISH TRAY AND DINNER ROLLS Steak Selections* (All Steaks USDA choice) Toby’s Special: Our signature 6oz. top sirloin cooked to order served with toast....$14.95 Top Sirloin: A 12oz version of our Toby’s special for the heartier appetite. Sorry no room for toast on this one....$21.95 Filet: 8oz Center cut beef tenderloin cooked to order....$22.95 Ribeye: A 12oz cut of marbled flavorful beef grilled to order....$27.95 New York Strip: 12oz portion of choice strip steak cooked to order....$26.95 T- Bone: Like two steaks in one, a flavorful strip and filet together grilled for a juicy taste....$26.95 Ground Sirloin: 12oz of lean ground beef pattied per order and grilled to your liking....$14.95 Top off any steak selection with: Sautéed Mushrooms....$3.00 Sautéed Onions....$1.00 Bleu Cheese....$2.00 Garlic Pesto....$2.00 STEAKS DONE AS FOLLOWS: Rare- Red Center Medium Rare- Red Warm center Medium- Pink Hot center Medium Well & Well- Grey Hot center Not responsible for well done or extra well done steaks! All Steaks USDA choice & NO Tenderizers added *Wis. Food Agencies advise that eating raw under cooked meats, poultry, eggs, or seafood pose a health risk to everyone, especially the elderly, young children, pregnant women, and other susceptible individuals with compromised immune systems. Thorough cooking of such animal foods reduces the risk of illness. Burgers & steaks cooked rare, medium rare or pink in the middle may be under cooked & are served only upon customer request. ALL DINNERS ARE SERVED WITH CHOICE OF SALAD OR SOUP, POTATO, RELISH TRAY AND DINNER ROLLS Seafood* Cod: Toby’s signature cod lightly breaded and deep fried OR broiled....2 piece $14.95 3 piece $17.95 Lake Perch: Fresh from our own Great Lakes, lightly breaded and deep fried to a golden brown....$21.95 Blue Gill: Wild caught small filets, lightly breaded and deep fried....$16.95 Baby Pike: Wild caught Canadian Walleye lightly breaded and deep fried....$18.95 Frog Legs: 3 Saddles lightly breaded and deep fried....$14.95 Salmon*: 8oz grilled filet served with a lemon dill sauce. (Not available on Fridays)...$18.95 Shrimp: 5 piece jumbo shrimp butterflied, lightly breaded and deep fried....$24.95 Grilled Shrimp: 5 piece jumbo shrimp grilled topped with garlic pesto....$24.95 African Lobster Tail: One or two 7oz cold water tails served split with drawn butter....$Market Steak & Lobster Tail: 6oz Top sirloin steak served with a 7oz tail on the side....$Market Steak & Shrimp: 6oz Top sirloin steak served with 3 jumbo shrimp grilled or deep fried on the side....$26.95 Steak & Lake Perch: 6oz Top sirloin steak accompanied by a hearty portion of perch....$24.95 Steak & Blue Gill: 6oz Top sirloin steak served with a plentiful side of Blue Gill filets....$22.95 Steak & Cod: 6oz Top sirloin steak paired up with 2 pieces of our crowd favorite cod. Deep fried or broiled....$23.95 Shrimp & Lake Perch: These two crowd favorites plated together to make this popular combo....$24.95 Shrimp & Blue Gill: Always a satisfying pair when choosing a combo plate....$22.95 (All seafood dishes served with one portion of our homemade tarter sauce, cocktail sauce, and lemon, $0.50 charge per extra sauce) *Wis. Food Agencies advise that eating raw under cooked meats, poultry, eggs, or seafood pose a health risk to everyone, especially the elderly, young children, pregnant women, and other susceptible individuals with compromised immune systems. Thorough cooking of such animal foods reduces the risk of illness. Burgers & steaks cooked rare, medium rare or pink in the middle may be under cooked & are served only upon customer request. Chicken & Pork Pan Fried Chicken: A definite crowd favorite thanks to Toby’s wife Lila’s secret recipe. You get a half a chicken breaded and pan fried to a crispy golden brown. If the Colonel’s chicken was this good he would have been a General....$15.95 All white meat....$18.95 Pork Ribeye*: A great alternative to chops, a 8oz flavorful cut of pork cooked to your liking and served with a side of apple sauce....$14.95 Hand Helds (served ala carte) Toby’s Burger*: A juicy burger freshly pattied to order. Served with choice of lettuce, tomato and onion on a toasted Brioche roll....$8.95 Add Cheese....$0.50 Add bacon....$2.00 Steak*: A tender 6oz sirloin prepared to your liking served on a toasted Brioche roll....$10.95 Grilled Chicken Breast: 6oz chicken breast grilled to perfection. Served with choice of lettuce, tomato and onion on a toasted Brioche roll.....$8.95 Crispy Chicken: 6oz southwestern breaded breast deep fried to a golden brown. Served with choice of lettuce, tomato and mayo on a toasted Brioche roll....$8.95 Fish Sandwich: Our popular cod loin breaded and fried to a golden brown. Served with choice of lettuce, tomato and tartar sauce on a toasted Brioche roll....7.95 Grilled Cheese: You choose the cheese and we will grill it to a golden brown on white or wheat bread....$4.95 Add French Fries to any Hand Held selection....$3.00 Salad Selections Chicken Caesar: Fresh cut romaine lettuce tossed with classic caesar dressing, black olives, grated parmesan cheese & homemade croutons. Finished off with a grilled seasoned chicken breast....$11.95 Grilled Chicken: Mixed greens topped with cheddar cheese, bacon bits, fresh mushrooms, tomatoes, onions and homemade croutons with a grilled chicken breast. Served with your choice of dressing....$11.95 Homemade Dressing choices: French, Thousand Island, Italian, Ranch, Honey Mustard, Parmesan Peppercorn, Creamy blue cheese or French blue cheese - ($0.75 extra for blue cheese) *Wis. Food Agencies advise that eating raw under cooked meats, poultry, eggs, or seafood pose a health risk to everyone, especially the elderly, young children, pregnant women, and other susceptible individuals with compromised immune systems. Thorough cooking of such animal foods reduces the risk of illness. Burgers & steaks cooked rare, medium rare or pink in the middle may be under cooked & are served only upon customer request.